Jen wiggled as much as she could, but the straps held tight. It added a certain sort of claustrophobia to the terror she was already feeling. The idea of not being free to move sent a horrible feeling up and down her spine. Part of her even wished she could slip back into unconsciousness.
She heard the locks on the door being opened. Slowly, casually. She knew it was Danny, and not a rescue of some sort. A rescue would be urgent and rushed. Danny wasn’t rushed at all. He seemed to be savoring every moment of this. Always far calmer than she would expect under the circumstances.
The door opened and Danny came in, setting a paper bag of groceries on the work bench to the side of the garage where Jen had spent the last three days. He turned to her and smiled. His smile wasn’t mad or deranged. It was that same winning smile Danny had always shown her in the eight years she’d known him. But of course, she hadn’t known her best friend. The Danny she thought she knew would never have been capable of any of this. It made it all even worse somehow. It’s terrible enough to be abducted, tortured, with no hope of escape and the promise that she would be killed in time. That it was Danny, her sweet Danny, was just too much.
“How are you holding up, my dear?”
“Please, just let me go. Danny, this can’t be you. We can fix this. You haven’t done anything yet that can’t be reversed. Please, just undo these straps and we can get you help.”
He smiled again, his face patient and indulgent, the same way he would smile at a child trying to talk her way out of bed time.
“Oh, I’ve done plenty that can’t be reversed, Jen. You’re not the first person I’ve had in this position. I’m up to 32, before you. You’ll be my number 33. And 3 is a very special number, so 33 must be twice as special.”
His tone of voice was far too gentle and kind, it was obscenely incongruent with the horrible words he was saying.
Jen moaned. The hopelessness was growing. She’d been trying to keep from crying, but in this moment she was losing that particular battle.
“Why, Danny? Why are you doing these things? Why are you doing them to me?”
Danny pursed his lips and and took a deep breath. He shook his head, just slightly. “Oh, Jen. I was worried about this. You’re thinking that it’s all been a lie. That I haven’t cared about you all these years we’ve been friends. But that’s just not it. I’m doing this because I care about you.
“You see, we have to seize life while we are living. We should try to experience everything we can before we go. Travel the world. Drink fine wine, and expensive whiskey. Have great sex and try illicit substances. Eat different sorts of foods that sound delicious as well as those that sound terrible. Life is to be lived!”
Jen looked at Danny. She felt a small flicker of hope. He was clearly insane, but maybe in some twisted way he wanted to show her how precious her life was, inspire her to live more fully.
“Does this mean you’ll let me go? As long as I’ve learned that I need to get more out of life than I have been? Because I promise I will, Danny. I see now!”
“Oh, no. I’m so sorry, sweetie. This isn’t an experience for you. This is an experience for me. I don’t just want to try doing good things, or else I will be missing an entire realm of experiences that life has to offer me. I don’t just want to see what it feels like to cause pleasure. I want to see what it was like to cause pain. I have become a connoisseur of suffering, the same way I am a connoisseur of so many other of life’s passions and wonders.
“I’ve tortured people of different races and cultures. I’ve slowly killed people of different religions to see the constrast in how they act as they die. I’ve murdered children and the elderly, to see how it feels. I’ve tasted so many of the different flavors of death. And yet, one thing I haven’t experienced is what it feels like to cause pain and death for someone I love, and I love you most of all. You’re my closest friend, and not a single moment of that has been faked. I need to see how it feels to kill you, Jen. To feel the delight and the horror. To wrestle with the remorse and the grief after you’re gone. You will offer me so many feelings and experiences I’ve never had before. It’s the greatest gift you’ve ever given me.”
His voice was still gentle, but he was clearly getting excited. There was a rising note of that passion she’d heard in his voice so many times before when he was talking about all the amazing things he loved and enjoyed. That was part of what had drawn her to him in the first place, that boundless love of living he had. It was so horrible, to hear him use that same tone now to explain how thrilled he was to kill her.
There was nothing left to do but scream.